The primary causes of Arc Flash

Potential causes of an Arc Flash or Arcing Fault may include:

  • Workers mistakenly dropping tools on live parts
  • Pests entering switchgear through openings
  • Faulty operation of a load break switch
  • Dust or moisture accumulating to weaken air insulated bus bars
  • Improper use of test equipment

Electricians Testing Equipment

From personal experience onsite and reading incident reports, the last three are the ones that are mostly likely going to be the cause of an Arc Fault.

Faulty Switches

Within an utility, institutional and industrial setting, electrical equipment does not always get the proper maintenance that it requires to have optimal operation.  With age, the ability of these mechanical devices to extinguish faults diminishes causing potential catastrophic failures

Electricians have been trained for a very long time to operate these breakers, switches etc from an arms length distance to the side.  This minimizes their body exposure to a possible failure.

Dust and Moisture

Industrial facilities such as refineries, pulp and paper plants, etc are not very clean environments, and as such there is a risk that there will be faults with electrical equipment due to the build-up of dust or introduction of moisture within the enclosures.  Modern company standards for electrical rooms have reflected this with the introdction of solid-state drives that are not as forgiving to dusty environments, and as such the new electrical equipment rooms are typically under static pressure to better control the enviroment.  PotashCorp of Saskatchewan is an example of one of the companies that are following this methodology.

This said, there are many existing electrical rooms that remain without such methodology.  To ensure that employees that usually work in these rooms are at the very least moderately protected, one company that I have worked with has a standard practice that anyone working in these rooms must wear 8 Calorie/cm² coveralls and safety glasses.  This level of PPE meets the majority of Incident Energy Levels within the electrical rooms in that facility.

Improper Use of Test Equipment

In the modern maintainence and operation of facilities the governing philosphy is to do all work on electrical equipment only after it has been grounded and isolated from the system.  This ensures that it is at a zero energy state and the risk of electrocution is minimized as much as possible.

There are still a number of situations that this is simply not practical, the most often offender being during commissioning or trouble shooting.  These activities most often requires the worker to test the voltage of the equipment to ensure they match the expected values.  With older test equipment, and cheaper modern equipment, there is a risk that the worker will not have the test equipment set properly.  If they try to check the voltage of a busbar while the meter is set for current, it acts like a short circuit and this will cause a fault that may lead to an arcing fault, which may lead to an ingury to the worker or people standing by.

What can you do.

One of the things that you can do to help mitigate a serious injury is to wear the correct PPE when working on equipment that has not be verified to be at a zero energy state.  Recent standard releases within North America (NFPA 70E in the US, and CSA Z462 in Canada) the level of PPE required when the possible incident energy is known.  If the levels are not known, speak with your managers and ask them to inform you of what the levels are.

When planning to work on live equipment, ensure that there is a job plan and everyone knows what their roles will be and what the emergency plan is.  With a comprehensive emergencuy plan an incident has a better chance to be contained and not excalating to harm others.

Arc Flash Hazard

When an electric current passes through air between ungrounded conductors or between ungrounded and grounded conductors, the temperatures can reach 35000F.

Exposure to these extreme temperatures both burns the skin and causes the ingnition of clothing. Each year more than 2000 people are admitted to burn centers with severe arc-flash burns.

An arc-flash can and do kill at distances 10ft or greater.

Source: NFPA 70E-2004, Annex K.3

What is NFPA 70E

According to the title of the NFPA 70E standard it is the "Standard for Electrical Safety in the Workplace". And that is just what it is. Now the better question would have been, do I need to understand NFPA 70E in my workplace?

Or how does NFPA 70E apply to me?

The typical workplaces that are covered by NFPA 70E are buildings, utilities, yards, parking lots, etc. However it does not cover ships, watercraft, underground mine installations, communication equipment and installations that are under the exclusive control of the electric utility.

In the last few years, NFPA 70E has been known synonymously with Arc Flash and Arc Flash PP. However that is only a small part of the standard in the whole. Arc Flash and Arc Flash PPE are covered only in Article 130, Working On or Near Live Parts. It is in this section that NFPA 70E talks about Limited Approach Boundarys as based on System Votage (Table 130.2(C)), the Protective Clothing and PPE Matrix (Table 130.7(C)(10)) and has many other useful tables to help to educate how to work on live equipment in the safest manner.

In fact if you go to the index the only place that the term Arc Flash is used is in Annex K. It is here where you can find a definition of what Arc Flash is, and the difference between Arc Flash and Arc Blast.

Some of the topics that NFPA 70E do discuss in depth is how to do maintence in different situations including Hazardous Locations, rotating equipment, Battery Rooms, and the PPE required in these situations. One thing the NFPA 70E stresses is that PPE is a last line of defense. Whenever possible Electrically and Mecahnically isolated the system that you or your employee is going to work on.

Finally NFPA 70E has great information in its Annexes. Some of this includes establishing a "Electrical Safety Program", "Job Briefing and Planning Checklist" and "Cross reference Tables".

If you work on energized equipment, even if it is only once a month or less. NFPA 70E will be evaluable to you in educating yourself and others on the risks involved and how to mitigate them most reasonably.

Finally if you liked this article or have questions please leave a comment.

Welcome to the Sparky Resource

Welcome to the site.  Sparky Resource is my pet project to discuss Arc Flash and all related matters.  I will be posting articles about NFPA, IEEE and other related materials.  Solutions, problems and news.

I hope to discuss the topic with little if any "sales prejudice" since I am a consulting engineer for a medium sized General Engineering firm.  I will discuss different presentations that I have been to that were given by fuse manufacturers, breaker manufacturers and try to point out the prejudices that are evident in what they say, and why you have to take everything that people tell you as defintes regarding Arc Flash with a grain of salt.

There will be some articles that will be technical in nature, so if you are reading this and don't understand something please be sure to make a comment asking for clarification.  I will do my best to help you fulling understand the topics.